If you are looking for an alternative to one of these seven tools, the quickest filter is assistants, then allowance. On the vendor pages I read on 22 November 2026, only 3 of 7 list ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Copilot together on a self-serve tier (AthenaHQ, Otterly and Ahrefs Brand Radar). On my six published-facts criteria Peec AI scored 10 of 12, Otterly 9, AthenaHQ, Scrunch and Ahrefs 8, Semrush 6 and Profound 5. That score measures transparency and fit, not accuracy, which I did not test.
Disclosure. I am Shruti Kaushik. I run Wise Mango, Inc., which offers AI visibility audits, and I founded Klype AI, whose site lists an AI Visibility Check. I benefit if you choose either, so read the Klype section and the scoring with that in mind. I have not used any of the seven tools below as a customer. I give no vendor prices here, because they change and several pages contradict themselves. Each entry links to the vendor's own pricing page, which is where you should read the current figure.
Everything below comes from the vendors' own pages or from named press coverage, opened on 22 November 2026. Where a page was silent, I write "not published". A longer reference covering 12 tools is AI visibility tools compared: 12 tools. This one takes seven names people search for and scores them on one rubric.
#The short version
| Question | Answer from pages read on 22 Nov 2026 |
|---|---|
| How many of the 7 list all five of ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Copilot on a self-serve tier? | 3: AthenaHQ (Starter), Otterly (every plan, with a page contradiction), Ahrefs (Custom Prompts) |
| How many describe how answers are collected? | 2 in some detail: Ahrefs (index method) and Semrush (Brand Performance only). Peec AI separates app engines from API models on Enterprise. The other 4 do not say |
| How many state daily refresh on the page? | 6 of 7. AthenaHQ does not state a frequency. Ahrefs says monthly for its Index, daily for Custom Prompts |
| How many publish a free tier, free trial or free preview? | 5 of 7: AthenaHQ (free plan), Scrunch (7-day trial), Otterly and Peec AI (trial button, length not stated), Ahrefs (free preview checker). Semrush says no trial. Profound states none |
| Largest numeric allowance published | Scrunch Core, 15,000 AI responses a month. Peec AI Advanced, 31,500 answers a month on 3 models |
| Only tool with no public self-serve plan | Profound. Its page says Starter and Growth were retired in September 2026 |
#How I scored them
I used six criteria. Each scores 0, 1 or 2, so the maximum is 12. Every score is based only on what the vendor's page said when I read it. A score of 0 means "not published", which is different from "does not do this".
- Assistant coverage. 2 if all five of ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Copilot are listed on a self-serve plan. 1 if four are listed, or all five only on an add-on or Enterprise tier. 0 if fewer than four are named anywhere.
- Collection method. 2 if the page describes how answers are gathered for the main product (for example, how an index is built). 1 if it does so for part of the product, or separates app engines from API models. 0 if not published.
- Refresh and allowance. 2 if both a refresh rate and a numeric allowance (prompts, answers, checks or credits) are stated. 1 if only one is. 0 if neither.
- Action layer. 2 if the product pairs tracking with both page or content actions and crawler or agent traffic data. 1 if it has one of those. 0 if tracking only.
- Entry access. 2 if a free plan, free trial or free preview is stated. 1 if there is a public self-serve plan but no trial. 0 if buying requires a sales conversation.
- Export and API. 2 if export and an API (including as a paid add-on) are available on a self-serve plan. 1 if only one is, or if both are Enterprise only. 0 if neither is stated.
These map to what a buyer can verify before paying. They do not capture accuracy, sampling quality or support. I list the tools alphabetically in the table rather than by score, and a one-point gap is inside my own judgment calls, so do not read the order of scores as a verdict.
#The scored comparison table
| Tool | Assistant coverage | Collection method | Refresh and allowance | Action layer | Entry access | Export and API | Total (of 12) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ahrefs Brand Radar | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 8 |
| AthenaHQ | 2 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 8 |
| Otterly | 1 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 9 |
| Peec AI | 1 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 10 |
| Profound | 1 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 5 |
| Scrunch | 1 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 8 |
| Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | 0 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 6 |
Three judgment calls:
- Otterly scores 1 on coverage, not 2. Its page lists seven engines including Claude and Copilot, and its comparison table says every plan can track every engine. But its plan cards say "4 of 7" engines. With two statements in conflict, I scored the conservative reading.
- Ahrefs scores 0 on export and API because the page I read did not state either. Ahrefs may offer both elsewhere.
- Klype AI is not in the table. Its site names an AI Visibility Check but, on the page I read, does not say which assistants it queries, how it collects answers, or what it outputs. It would score 0 on several criteria for lack of published facts, which says nothing about quality. I discuss it below.
#The seven tools, one at a time
Each entry gives the facts read on 22 November 2026, where it fits, and what to check against. For current prices, use the pricing link in each entry.
AthenaHQ
What its page publishes (AthenaHQ pricing). A free Essential plan, a self-serve Starter plan and a custom Enterprise plan. One credit equals one AI response. Starter lists 3,600 credits a month, with credits rolling over for one month. Essential lists 300 credits. Starter names 11 models: ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral. Topics, prompts and competitors are unlimited on Starter and Enterprise. Integrations listed on Starter are Shopify, Webflow, GA4 and Google Search Console, with CSV export. API access and extra credits are paid add-ons. Enterprise adds BI connectors (Tableau, Power BI, Looker), SAML and OIDC single sign-on, and a 2-hour support SLA.
What it does not publish. Update frequency, on any plan. Collection method. The page also lists a $300 free credit on Starter without saying whether it is a trial, so confirm it before relying on it.
Score: 8 of 12. Full marks on coverage, entry access and export plus API, but no collection method and no refresh rate.
Fits if you want the longest named model list and unlimited prompts, and you are comfortable managing a credit budget. With 3,600 credits at one per response, the credit pool is the cap, not the prompt count. For example, 24 prompts across 5 assistants daily for 30 days uses 3,600 responses (24 times 5 times 30).
AthenaHQ alternatives to check first. Peec AI and Otterly if you want a published refresh rate and a prompt count. Scrunch if you want a published monthly response volume and page-level work. Ahrefs Brand Radar if you want an index you did not have to write.
Scrunch
What its page publishes (Scrunch pricing). Two plans: Core, billed monthly with a 7-day free trial, and Enterprise, billed yearly after a demo. Core lists eight engines: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Microsoft Copilot, Grok and Meta AI. Enterprise adds Claude as an add-on. Collection is daily on Core, and daily or every 3 days on Enterprise. Core limits: 15,000 AI responses a month, 1 brand, 5 competitors, 5 seats, 3 AI search trend topics, 10 citation targets a month, 100 fact-checked pages a month, 10 pages optimised, 10 pages generated, and agent traffic on 1 domain. Data exports and MCP are on both plans. API keys and Data Studio are Enterprise only.
What it does not publish. How answers are collected.
Score: 8 of 12. It loses a point on coverage because Claude is an Enterprise add-on, loses another because it has no collection method, and loses a point on API because keys are Enterprise only.
Fits if you want tracking and page work together for one brand, and Claude is not on your must-have list. The Core plan is one brand, so an agency or a multi-brand company moves into a sales conversation quickly.
Scrunch AI alternatives to check first. Profound (agent analytics and an AI marketer product), Peec AI (crawl insights and agent credits in every plan) and AthenaHQ if Claude must be on a self-serve tier.
Profound
What its page publishes (Profound pricing). A single Enterprise plan with custom pricing. The page says Starter and Growth were retired in September 2026 and are not available to new subscribers. It tracks up to 10 answer engines: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, Gemini, DeepSeek, Claude, Google AI Overviews, Exa Search, Muse Spark and Qwen. Prompt frequency is daily. Prompts tracked, languages and regions are custom. Agent Analytics supports unlimited domains with integrations that include Akamai, AWS, Cloudflare, Fastly, Google Analytics, Netlify, Vercel and WordPress. Prompt Volumes keeps all-time history. Exports are CSV and JSON, with an API. Seats are unlimited. Security lists SSO/SAML and SOC 2.
Press context. Fortune reported on 24 February 2026 that Profound raised a $96 million Series C led by Lightspeed Venture Partners at a $1 billion valuation, and that the company says it has more than 700 enterprise customers (Fortune). The customer count is the company's claim as reported, which I did not verify.
What it does not publish. A trial, any numeric allowance, whether Copilot is tracked, or how answers are collected.
Score: 5 of 12. It scores 0 on entry access because the page offers no self-serve route, and 0 on collection method. That is a statement about public information, not product quality, and a sales-led vendor can answer these in a demo.
Fits if you are an enterprise team that wants one quote-based platform with traffic analytics, SOC 2 and a dedicated specialist (the page lists a 24-hour SLA).
Profound alternatives to check first. Scrunch and Peec AI for the same tracking-plus-actions shape on self-serve plans. There is a separate page on Profound alternatives, which compares six other tools on the same published facts.
Peec AI
What its page publishes (Peec AI pricing). Three self-serve brand plans (Starter, Pro, Advanced) and an Enterprise plan. Prompts are 50, 150 and 350 on the three self-serve plans, and unlimited on Enterprise. Monthly AI answers are 4,500, 13,500 and 31,500, which is prompts times 3 models times 30 days. Tracking is daily on every plan. Starter, Pro and Advanced each choose 3 models from ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overview, AI Mode, Gemini, Naver AI Briefing, ERNIE and Bing AI Mode. Enterprise adds 18 API-based models for up to 26, with examples including Claude Sonnet, Claude Opus, Grok, DeepSeek and Mistral variants. Extra models are available as paid add-ons. Countries are 1, 3 and 3 on the self-serve plans. Crawl insights (bot visits) are 4.5 million, 13.5 million and 31.5 million. API is included from Pro, and the Looker Studio connector from Advanced. A "Start free trial" button is listed without a stated length, and the page says agencies have separate pricing.
What it does not publish. A named Copilot engine. The page's Enterprise description also reads "up to 26" while a table cell shows "unlimited", so confirm the model count with Peec before buying.
Score: 10 of 12. It is the only tool of the seven that combines a numeric answer allowance, daily refresh, crawl data, an API on a self-serve tier and a trial button. It scores 1 on coverage because the self-serve plans choose 3 of 8 and Copilot is not named.
Fits if you want a fixed prompt list, clear answer counts and multi-country tracking, and three assistants are enough for your buyers.
Peec AI alternatives to check first. Otterly if you want more engines on the entry plan, and AthenaHQ if you want more than three assistants without an Enterprise contract. There is a separate page on Peec AI alternatives.
Otterly
What its page publishes (Otterly pricing). Lite, Standard and Premium self-serve plans plus Enterprise. Prompts are 16, 120 and 403, with 2,000, 15,000 and 50,000 monthly credits. One credit is one prompt checked once on one engine, Claude costs 3 credits per check, and a prompt tracked daily on one engine uses 31 credits a month. Engines are ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot, Google AI Mode, Gemini and Claude, with more listed as coming soon. Tracking is daily on all plans, and daily or weekly on Premium and Enterprise. Seats, brands, competitors, countries and languages are unlimited on every plan. API and MCP requests start on Standard, along with agent analytics events and a Data Studio connector. Free trials are offered on the three self-serve plans without a stated length.
What it does not publish. Collection method. The page also contradicts itself twice. Its meta description shows prompt counts of 15, 100 and 400 where the body shows 16, 120 and 403, and the plan cards say "4 of 7" engines while the comparison table says every plan can track every engine.
Score: 9 of 12. Strong on allowance, refresh, access and API. The coverage score drops to 1 because of the engine contradiction.
Fits if you want Claude and Copilot on an entry plan and can live inside credit arithmetic. Because Claude costs 3 credits a check, a Claude-heavy prompt list uses credits fastest.
Otterly alternatives to check first. Peec AI for answer counts instead of credits, and AthenaHQ for response credits at 1 per check on every model. There is a separate page on Otterly alternatives.
Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit
What its page publishes (Semrush knowledge base). An AI Visibility Score against the median of top industry competitors, Brand Performance (share of voice, sentiment, tone, attributes and key narratives), Prompt Research, Prompt Tracking and an AI Search Site Audit that flags technical issues that could block AI crawlers. ChatGPT and Google AI Mode are named. The page says tracking works on "platforms like" these, so others are not confirmed. Visibility Overview, Competitor Research and Prompt Research update daily. Prompt Tracking is daily and Brand Performance is weekly, with the Site Audit run on demand. Base limits include 1 project, 1 Brand Performance domain, 25 tracked prompts, 300 AI Analysis queries a day and up to 100 pages for the Site Audit. Semrush One plans lift prompts to 50, 100 or 200. The page states there is no trial.
What it does not publish. A full assistant list, which is why it scores 0 on coverage. Collection is described only for Brand Performance, which runs a set of common queries through the LLMs and analyses the responses.
Score: 6 of 12.
Fits if you already work in Semrush, want ChatGPT and AI Mode trends next to your SEO data, and want a crawler-readability audit in the same login.
Semrush alternatives to check first. Otterly, Peec AI or AthenaHQ if you need more assistants named on the page.
Ahrefs Brand Radar
What its page publishes (Ahrefs Brand Radar). Four metrics: mentions (brand name in answer text), citations (links to your pages), AI Share of Voice, and Estimated Impressions weighted by the search volume behind each prompt. The AI Visibility Index covers AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini and Perplexity, built from 581 million or more pre-collected prompts, with historical responses going back to 2025. Its question sets are re-tested monthly on a 90-day reporting window. A separate search-query index tracks which Google keywords trigger AI Overviews or AI Mode and whether you appear. Custom Prompts add Claude, which uses 8 checks per update. Custom Prompts plans are 150, 300 and 600 checks a month for 5, 10 and 20 prompts, with Enterprise from 2,500 checks. Refresh is daily in the pricing table, while the FAQ says you can choose daily, weekly or monthly per platform. There is no free trial stated, but a free preview through the AI Visibility Checker and free beta access to Bot Analytics are listed.
What it does not publish. The page says the Index may have limited coverage for brands with little or no search volume. It does not state an API or export on the Brand Radar page. It also shows a "$699/mo for all models" label without saying which product it applies to, and the pricing section and FAQ differ on Claude in the Index, so confirm both with Ahrefs.
Score: 8 of 12. The only vendor to score 2 on collection method.
Fits if you already pay for Ahrefs and want market-level share of voice without writing a prompt list. The cost is control: you are measured on a prompt set you did not choose, and an early-stage B2B brand with little search volume may be thinly covered.
Ahrefs Brand Radar alternatives to check first. For prompts you choose, Peec AI, Otterly or AthenaHQ. For a pre-built, large index on an enterprise contract, Profound is the nearest comparison on the page facts.
#Klype AI, described fairly
I founded Klype AI, so weigh this section accordingly. Klype's site lists an AI Visibility Check under its free tools, described as a way to "find out whether AI assistants name your company when buyers ask" (Klype AI). The page I read does not say which assistants it queries, how it collects answers, how often it refreshes, or what the output contains. I claim no user, customer or revenue figure for Klype.
What that means for you: Klype is better read as a free first look than as a like-for-like replacement for the tools above, which are built for recurring tracking against a prompt list. It is not scored because the six criteria depend on published facts it has not published, and a table of zeros would be misleading. If you want ongoing tracking with documented allowances, the seven scored tools publish more detail today.
My other business, Wise Mango, offers AI visibility audits. Its site describes a free check that tests up to 10 of your buyers' questions in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Mode and emails you within 3 working days with which brands are named, which are cited and five fixes most likely to help (Wise Mango). The same page links to a separate AI visibility audit and does not say whether the two are the same offering. None of these are scored.
#Which to choose if
You need all five of ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Copilot on a self-serve plan. AthenaHQ Starter, Otterly or Ahrefs Custom Prompts. Confirm Otterly's engine-per-plan contradiction first. Check the Claude cost: it is 3 credits a check at Otterly and 8 checks per update at Ahrefs, so it is the most expensive engine to track on both.
You want the cleanest allowance maths. Peec AI. It states the formula, prompts times models times days, and gives 4,500, 13,500 and 31,500 answers a month on its self-serve plans.
You already pay for Semrush or Ahrefs. Start with the add-on you already have. Semrush gives daily prompt tracking on ChatGPT and AI Mode and an AI crawler audit. Ahrefs gives a pre-built index and Custom Prompts. Semrush is weakest on a published assistant list, and Ahrefs on API and export on its product page.
You want tracking and page work in one product. Scrunch (pages optimised, pages generated, agent traffic), Profound (Agent Analytics, AI Marketer), AthenaHQ (content optimisation agent) or Peec AI (crawl insights and agent credits).
You are an enterprise buyer with security reviews. Profound lists SOC 2 and SSO/SAML. Scrunch lists a security review and custom terms on Enterprise. AthenaHQ lists SAML and OIDC and an audit log on Enterprise. Ask each for its collection method and a raw-answer export before signing.
You have no budget yet. Use AthenaHQ's free plan, a Scrunch or Otterly trial, Ahrefs' free preview, or the manual test below.
Free manual test. Write 10 buyer questions, ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity each 5 times in a fresh logged-out session, and record every brand and cited URL. The Contender author suggests about 5 runs per key prompt per pull, and 100 or more for high precision, so this is a rough read (Search Engine Land).
Before paying any of them, ask three things: whether answers come from the consumer app or the API, how many times each prompt is run per reading, and whether you can export every raw answer with its cited URLs. Only Ahrefs and Semrush describe collection for part of their products on the pages read, and Peec AI separates app engines from API models only at Enterprise, so for the other four the first two questions have no public answer.
#What the studies say about any score
Two datasets matter because every tool above reports a sample of a noisy system.
SparkToro and Gumshoe.ai. As reported by Search Engine Journal on 30 January 2026, SparkToro's Rand Fishkin and Patrick O'Donnell of Gumshoe.ai ran 2,961 prompts across ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI (AI Mode when Overviews did not appear). Twelve brand-recommendation prompts were each run 60 to 100 times per platform by hundreds of volunteers over November and December. The result was under a 1 in 100 chance that ChatGPT or Google's AI returned the same brand list twice, and under 0.1% for the same list in the same order. Claude was slightly more consistent. In a separate test, 142 participants wrote headphone prompts, and Bose, Sony, Sennheiser and Apple appeared in 55% to 77% of 994 responses. The study is not peer reviewed, respondents used their own AI settings, and Gumshoe.ai sells AI tracking, which Fishkin disclosed (Search Engine Journal). I read the write-up, not the raw data.
Contender. Mike Sonders of Contender ran 12 prompts (6 competitive B2B categories, 6 niche) 100 times each, 1,200 interactions. ChatGPT named about 44 brands per 100 responses for a prompt and about 10 brands in each single response. Only about 5 brands, 11% of those named, appeared in 80% or more of responses (Search Engine Land). Contender sells an AI search tool, and I read the write-up, not the raw data.
In practice a rank such as "you are number 3" is one draw, and a share across many draws is closer to the signal.
#Limits of this comparison
- Scores reflect published facts, not performance. I did not test accuracy, coverage quality or support. A vendor scoring 0 on collection method may publish it in a document I did not read.
- Pages contradict themselves. Otterly (engines per plan, prompt counts), Peec AI (Enterprise models), Ahrefs (Claude in the Index, refresh) and AthenaHQ (the $300 credit) each have conflicts that I flagged rather than resolved.
- A tool measures; it does not change what an assistant says. None of the seven pages promises a ranking outcome. For the work that moves answers, see how to get cited by ChatGPT and GEO agency vs consultant vs tool.
#Methodology
I opened each vendor page on 22 November 2026 using a page-fetch tool that returns extracted text and summaries rather than raw HTML, so figures are as that tool returned them. Pages read: the pricing pages for AthenaHQ, Scrunch, Profound, Peec AI and Otterly; Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit knowledge base article, as the product page was not the one opened; and Ahrefs' Brand Radar page, which includes its pricing. I also read the Klype AI and Wise Mango home pages, the Fortune article on Profound's funding, and the Search Engine Journal and Search Engine Land write-ups of the two variance studies. I did not read the original SparkToro or Contender data.
I scored each tool 0, 1 or 2 on six criteria defined above, using only the page text. Where a page stated two conflicting things, I scored the conservative reading and said so. Where a page was silent, I scored 0 and wrote "not published". The scores are my own judgment and an unweighted sum; weighting coverage or action layer more heavily would change the order, and one-point differences are within my judgment calls. The answers-per-month example for AthenaHQ is my arithmetic from the vendor's stated rule that one credit is one response.
No prices are stated. I did not test any tool as a customer, so nothing here is a verdict on accuracy or value. Pages change often, so check the vendor's page before buying.
Not verified and left out: independent accuracy tests of any tool, the share of answers collected from the consumer app versus the API, Klype AI's assistants, method and output, and any user, customer or revenue figure for any vendor beyond the single Profound claim attributed to Fortune.
#Sources
- AthenaHQ, pricing. https://www.athenahq.ai/pricing (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Scrunch, pricing. https://scrunch.com/pricing (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Profound, pricing. https://www.tryprofound.com/pricing (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Peec AI, pricing. https://peec.ai/pricing (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Otterly, pricing. https://otterly.ai/pricing (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Semrush, AI Visibility Toolkit (knowledge base). https://www.semrush.com/kb/1493-ai-visibility-toolkit (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Ahrefs, Brand Radar. https://ahrefs.com/brand-radar (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Fortune, "As AI threatens search, Profound raises $96 million to help brands stay visible," 24 Feb 2026. https://fortune.com/2026/02/24/exclusive-as-ai-threatens-search-profound-raises-96-million-to-help-brands-stay-visible/ (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Search Engine Journal, coverage of the SparkToro and Gumshoe.ai study of AI recommendation consistency. https://www.searchenginejournal.com/ai-recommendations-change-nearly-every-query-sparktoro/566242 (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Search Engine Land, Contender study on repeated ChatGPT runs and brand visibility. https://searchengineland.com/repeated-chatgpt-runs-brand-visibility-468552 (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Klype AI, home page (AI Visibility Check, free tools). https://klype.ai (read 22 Nov 2026)
- Wise Mango, home page (free AI visibility check). https://wisemango.io (read 22 Nov 2026)